Watch Anthony Mackie and Paul Bettany Fight Over Who’s The Better Avenger

Who’s a better Marvel hero, the Falcon or Vision? It’s a question as old as time—or at least as old as Marvel Comics. The two will definitely be butting heads on opposite sites of a brutal super-powered battle in Captain America: Civil War, but in the meantime they’re going face to face in a completely different arena: the holiday shopping season. And MTV News’ Josh Horowitz  had to find that out the hard way.

In the latest episode of “After Hours,” Josh’s quest to find the perfect gift for his nephew is interrupted by none other than Paul Bettany and Anthony Mackie, who each make a case for why their Avengers character is the must-have toy of the year. As you can see, things get personal very, very quickly. Bettany did just direct Anthony Mackie in the movie Shelter, so clearly they know exactly how to push one another’s buttons.

So which will Josh chose? Guess you just have to watch to find out!