The American Horror Story Guys Got Freaked Out By Their Own Show

Turnabout is fair play as American Horror Story stars Evan Peters, Denis O’Hare, and Finn Wittrock attend opening night of Universal Studios’ 2016 Halloween Horror Nights over the weekend and are thoroughly terrified by the likes of Rubber Man and Twisty the Clown. How does it feel to be on the other side of the scares, fellas? Hmmm?

The trio’s escapade through Halloween Horror Nights—which features The Exorcist, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Halloween, Friday the 13th, A Nightmare on Elm Street, The Walking Dead, as well as AHS—was captured on camera. The AHS portion is a maze through Murder House, Freak Show, and Hotel‘s terrifying settings. Seriously, these guys made the BEST faces, and the internet needs to meme them accordingly.

They look calm, cool, and collected here, right?



Not anymore.



“Hello, Darkness, my old friend.”



Peters was reunited with the skeleton in his closet and didn’t know how to process his emotions.



And Wittrock wasn’t even on Murder House, but was still haunted by the infamous Rubber Man.



Of course, Twisty from Freak Show definitely had an axe to grind with Dandy Mott.



O’Hare was the brave one of the group.



Well, almost.



Thankfully, all three made it out alive—because they still have to finish up Roanoke.

@horrornights ##universalhhn2016

A photo posted by Denis O’Hare (@ohdenis) on

Well, we know both O’Hare and Peters will be on Season 6, but Wittrock has yet to be confirmed. Fingers crossed he at least has a limited role on the new season, because I can’t imagine this new nightmare without him.